Skip to content
Free Shipping on select Mother's Day Gifts while supplies last!*
  1. Home
  2. Returning Favorites

Returning Favorites

Bring the holidays home with all of our most-loved holiday favorites! They’re only back for the holiday season, so now’s the time to stock up on festive flavors like cheese balls and spreads, coffee, and Christmas gift baskets!

Returning Favorites

Selection will refresh the page with new results

Price

  • The following checkbox filters the products results after checking or unchecking.
  • The following checkbox filters the products results after checking or unchecking.

Shipping & Pick-Up

  • The following checkbox filters the products results after checking or unchecking.
  • The following checkbox filters the products results after checking or unchecking.

Type

  • The following checkbox filters the products results after checking or unchecking.
  • The following checkbox filters the products results after checking or unchecking.

Cheese

  • The following checkbox filters the products results after checking or unchecking.
  • The following checkbox filters the products results after checking or unchecking.

Condiments

  • The following checkbox filters the products results after checking or unchecking.
  • The following checkbox filters the products results after checking or unchecking.
  • The following checkbox filters the products results after checking or unchecking.
  • The following checkbox filters the products results after checking or unchecking.
  • The following checkbox filters the products results after checking or unchecking.
  • The following checkbox filters the products results after checking or unchecking.

Fruit & Nuts

  • The following checkbox filters the products results after checking or unchecking.

Sweets & Treats

  • The following checkbox filters the products results after checking or unchecking.
  • The following checkbox filters the products results after checking or unchecking.
Activating this element will cause content on the page to be updated.
24 Results
  • Sweet Hot Mustard 3-Pack

    $21.99
    This gift ships free!*
    • 10 oz Sweet Hot Mustard

    Try our most-loved combination! Pair Sweet Hot Mustard with Signature Beef Summer Sausage and Smoked Cheddar Blend for a classic, savory bite. Or, try it on sandwiches for an extra kick of flavor!

    Net weight 1.87 lbs

    Allergen Information:

    Product contains wheat and soy. Produced in a facility that also processes egg, milk, and tree nuts (pecans, almonds, coconut, cashews, walnuts).

    View More
    View Less
  • Sweet & Salty Nut Sampler

    $21.99
    • Honey Roasted Peanuts
    • Milk Chocolate Covered Peanuts
    • Cranberry & Sesame Nut mix
    • Roasted Salted Colossal Cashews
    • Glazed Almonds
    • Traditional Nut Mix

    Net weight 1.85 lbs

    Allergen Information:

    Product contains milk, peanut, wheat, cashews, almonds, Brazil nuts, pecans, and soy. Produced in a facility that also processes egg, and other tree nuts (coconut, walnuts).

    View More
    View Less
  • Cranberry Mustard 3-Pack

    $21.99
    • 10 oz Cranberry Mustard

    Pair Cranberry Mustard with Sweet & Smoky Turkey Summer Sausage and Farmhouse Cheddar for a sweet and savory flavor experience.

    Net weight 1.87 lbs

    Allergen Information:

    Produced in a facility that also processes milk, egg, wheat, soy, peanuts, and tree nuts (pecans, almonds, coconut, cashews, walnuts).

    View More
    View Less
  • Signature Mustard Flight

    $21.99
    • 10 oz Sweet Hot Mustard
    • 10 oz Honey Pineapple Mustard
    • 10 oz Cranberry Mustard

    Net weight 1.87 lbs

    Allergen Information:

    Product contains wheat and soy. Produced in a facility that also processes milk, egg, peanut, and tree nuts (pecans, almonds, coconut, cashews, walnuts).

    View More
    View Less
  • Snow Mints

    $27.99 $20.99
    Online Exclusive!*
    • (3) 10 oz Snow Mints

    Net weight 1.87 lbs

    Allergen Information:

    Product contains milk. Produced in a facility that also processes peanuts and tree nuts.

    View More
    View Less
  • Sweet & Sour Sauce 3-Pack

    $21.99
    • 9 oz Sweet & Sour Sauce

    Our Sweet & Sour Sauce tastes great in your favorite chicken wings recipe!

    Net weight 1.68 lbs

    Allergen Information:

    Produced in a facility that also processes milk, egg, wheat, soy, peanuts, and tree nuts (pecans, almonds, coconut, cashews, walnuts).

    View More
    View Less
  • Hot Pepper Bacon Jam 2-Pack

    $21.99
    • 11 oz Hot Pepper Bacon Jam

    Try Hot Pepper Bacon Jam paired with Three Pepper Dry Salami and Jalapeño Cheddar Blend for a savory, spicy bite.

    Net weight 1.37 lbs

    Allergen Information:

    Produced in a facility that also processes milk, egg, wheat, soy, peanuts, and tree nuts (pecans, almonds, coconut, cashews, walnuts).

    View More
    View Less
  • Sweet Hot Mustard 6 -Pack

    $43.98 $39.99
    Online Exclusive!*
    • 10 oz Sweet Hot Mustard

    Net weight 3.75 lbs

    Allergen Information:

    Product contains wheat and soy. Produced in a facility that also processes egg, milk, and tree nuts (pecans, almonds, coconut, cashews, walnuts)

    View More
    View Less
  • Sweet & Sour Sauce 6 -Pack

    $43.98 $39.99
    Online Exclusive!*
    • 9 oz Sweet & Sour Sauce

    Net weight 3.37 lbs

    Allergen Information:

    Produced in a facility that also processes milk, egg, wheat, soy, peanuts, and tree nuts (pecans, almonds, coconut, cashews, walnuts).

    View More
    View Less
  • Horseradish Sauce 3-Pack

    $21.99
    • 10 oz Horseradish Sauce

    We love our Horseradish Sauce paired with All-Natural Beef Summer Sausage and Farmhouse Cheddar for a snack that has tons of flavor. Or, enjoy it with grilled summer sausage for a delicious bite.

    Net weight 1.87 lbs

    Allergen Information:

    Product contains egg and soy. Produced in a facility that also processes milk, wheat, peanuts, and tree nuts (pecans, almonds, coconut, cashews, walnut).

    View More
    View Less
  • Spicy Sauces Flight

    $21.99
    • 10 oz.Sweet Hot Mustard
    • 10 oz Spicy Sriracha Mustard
    • 9 oz Chipotle Ranch Sauce

    Net weight 1.81 lbs

    Allergen Information:

    Product contains milk, egg, wheat, and soy. Produced in a facility that also processes peanuts, and tree nuts (pecans, almonds, coconut, cashews, walnuts).

    View More
    View Less
  • Chipotle Ranch Sauce 3-Pack

    $21.99
    • 9 oz Chipotle Ranch Sauce

    Try our Chiptole Ranch Sauce on a burger or to top nachos for a zesty kick of flavor.

    Net weight 1.68 lbs

    Allergen Information:

    Product contains egg milk, and soy. Produced in a facility that also processes wheat, peanuts, and tree nuts (pecans, almonds, coconut, cashews, walnut).

    View More
    View Less
  • Savory Sauces Flight

    $21.99
    • 10 oz Horseradish Sauce
    • 9 oz Chipotle Ranch Sauce
    • 9 oz Sweet & Sour Sauce

    Net weight 1.75 lbs

    Allergen Information:

    Product contains milk, wheat, egg, and soy. Produced in a facility that also processes peanuts and tree nuts (pecans, almonds, coconut, cashews, walnuts).

    View More
    View Less
  • Spicy Sriracha Mustard 3-Pack

    $21.99
    • 10 oz Spicy Sriracha Mustard

    Add Spicy Sriracha Mustard to your favorite sandwich to give it an extra kick of flavor!

    Net weight 1.87 lbs

    Allergen Information:

    Produced in a facility that also processes milk, egg, wheat, soy, peanuts, and tree nuts (pecans, almonds, coconut, cashews, walnuts).

    View More
    View Less
  • New York Cheddar Spread 3-Pack

    This item is currently not available.

    $36.99
    • 10 oz New York Cheddar Spread

    Net weight 1.87 lbs

    Allergen Information:

    Product contains milk. This product is gluten free.

    View More
    View Less
  • Cheese Ball Flight

    This item is currently not available.

    $36.99
    • 9 oz Original Blend Cheese Ball
    • 9 oz Sharp Cheddar Blend Cheese Ball
    • 9 oz Swiss Blend Cheese Ball

    Net weight 1.68 lbs

    Allergen Information:

    Product contains milk, almonds, and wheat. Produced in a facility that also processes eggs, soy, and tree nuts.

    View More
    View Less
  • Original Blend Cheese Ball 3-Pack

    This item is currently not available.

    $36.99
    • 9 oz Original Blend Cheese Ball

    Net weight 1.68

    Allergen Information:

    Product contains milk and almonds.

    View More
    View Less
  • Swiss Blend Cheese Ball 3-Pack

    This item is currently not available.

    $36.99
    • 9 oz Swiss Blend Cheese Ball

    Net weight 1.68 lbs

    Allergen Information:

    Product contains milk and almonds.

    View More
    View Less
  • Garden Vegetable Cheese Spread 3-Pack

    This item is currently not available.

    $36.99
    • 10 oz Garden Vegetable Cheese Spread

    Net weight 1.87 lbs

    Allergen Information:

    Product contains milk. May contain traces of soy, wheat, almonds, and pecans.

    View More
    View Less
  • Cheese Spread Flight

    This item is currently not available.

    $36.99
    • 10 oz Garden Vegetable Cheese Spread
    • 10 oz Pepper Jack Cheese Spread
    • 10 oz Garlic Mozzarella Cheese Spread

    Net weight 1.87 lbs

    Allergen Information:

    Product contains milk. Produced in a facility that also processes soy, wheat, egg, peanuts, and tree nuts (pecans, almonds, coconut, cashews, walnut).

    View More
    View Less
  • Pepper Jack Cheese Spread 3-Pack

    This item is currently not available.

    $36.99
    • 10 oz Pepper Jack Cheese Spread

    Net weight 1.87 lbs

    Allergen Information:

    Product contains milk. May contain traces of soy, wheat, almonds, and pecans.

    View More
    View Less
  • Garlic Mozzarella Cheese Spread 3-Pack

    This item is currently not available.

    $36.99
    • 10 oz Garlic Mozzarella Cheese Spread

    Net weight 1.87 lbs

    Allergen Information:

    Product contains milk. May contain traces of soy, wheat, almonds, and pecans.

    View More
    View Less
  • Sharp Cheddar Blend Cheese Ball 3-Pack

    This item is currently not available.

    $36.99
    • 9 oz Sharp Cheddar Blend Cheese Ball

    Net weight 1.68 lbs

    Allergen Information:

    Product contains milk and almonds.

    View More
    View Less
  • Bacon & Green Onion Cheese Spread 3-Pack

    This item is currently not available.

    $36.99
    • 10 oz Bacon & Green Onion Cheese Spread

    Net weight 1.87 lbs

    Allergen Information:

    Product contains milk. May contain traces of soy, wheat, almonds, and pecans.

    View More
    View Less

Bestselling Gift Baskets

Holiday food is a great way to add delicious, festive flavor to any holiday season event or party. If you’re hosting a party, start a new holiday tradition by serving hearty charcuterie boards! They’re an easy and stress-free Christmas appetizer that will wow your guests. Our best-selling Christmas gift baskets come with charcuterie essentials like summer sausage, cheese, mustard, and crackers to make building the perfect meat and cheese spread easy. And don’t forget to add a cheese ball or cheese spread to your holiday menu, they’re the life of the party!

Best Holiday Gifts 2023

If you’re looking to give the best gifts of the holiday season, send a gift basket filled with Christmas food to share. A gift basket filled with savory charcuterie favorites, tasty snacks, and sweet treats is the perfect gift for anyone on your list who loves delicious food. And if they love to enjoy their favorite wine alongside their snacks, we have Christmas wine gift baskets to make their holiday celebration even more fun.

Or, if you’re shopping for a sweet tooth, send them the gift of a Christmas dessert. Gourmet chocolates and cupcakes in jars are some holiday favorites they’ll love to unwrap. But don’t wait to order these bestselling gifts! Make sure you get yours before they’re gone.